How to Solve 'What Comes Next?' Picture Puzzles
By the Lucky Birthday team · 13 November 2026
Picture puzzles, where you look at a grid of shapes and choose the piece that completes it, appear in IQ tests, school entrance exams and puzzle books. They can look baffling at first, but they are built from a small number of rules, and once you know what to look for most of them become much easier. Lucky Birthday's Birthday Patterns game uses exactly this kind of puzzle, and you can try today's free puzzles without signing up.
The grid
Each puzzle is a 3 by 3 grid with the bottom right piece missing. You are given four options, and exactly one of them fits every rule in the grid. The others are usually close: most wrong answers break just one rule, so the trick is to find every rule before you choose.
The six things a piece can change
In our puzzles, a piece can differ from its neighbours in six ways. When you first look at a grid, check each one in turn:
- Shape: circle, square, triangle, diamond, star, heart, balloon or arrow.
- Colour.
- Count: how many shapes the piece holds, from one to four.
- Fill: whether the shapes are solid or just outlined.
- Size: small, medium or full size.
- Direction: which way the shape points, for arrows and hearts.
If something is the same in all eight pieces, you can forget about it: the answer will have it too. Concentrate on whatever changes.
Where to look: rows, columns, diagonals and reading order
Read along the rows first. Most rules work from left to right: something stays the same along a row, or goes up, or turns a step at a time. If the rows do not explain everything, read down the columns. If neither works, try the diagonals, from top left to bottom right. Finally, some puzzles are read like a page of a book, left to right and then on to the next row, with a pattern that carries straight across the row breaks.
Rule 1: steps along a row
The simplest rule is a steady step. For example, a row might show one star, then two stars, then three. Or a red arrow pointing up, then the same arrow pointing right, then pointing down: each piece turns a quarter turn further than the one before. Once you have spotted the step in the first two rows, apply it to the third.
Rule 2: sudoku rules
In a sudoku-style grid, each shape (or colour) appears exactly once in every row and every column. If the bottom row already has a heart and a balloon, and the right-hand column already has a star and a balloon, the missing piece must be the shape that is not yet in either: count what each row and column is missing. Harder puzzles use this rule twice at once, for shape and for colour, on different patterns.
Rule 3: sums
Some grids use simple arithmetic on the count. In each row, the third piece holds the first count plus the second: one shape and two shapes make three. A variation uses subtraction instead: four shapes take away one shape leaves three. These are easy to miss because the shapes themselves may not change at all.
Rule 4: either one, but not both
A trickier rule works on filled and outlined pieces. The third piece in a row is filled only when exactly one of the first two is filled. If both are filled, or neither is, the third is outlined. Logicians call this 'exclusive or'.
Rule 5: two or three rules at once
Hard puzzles combine rules. A common combination is shape set by the row, colour set by the column, and count going up along the diagonals. Another is size set by the column and direction set by the row. Take them one property at a time: settle the shape, then the colour, then the count, and see which option survives.
A method that works on any puzzle
- Look at what changes and ignore what stays the same.
- For each thing that changes, find the rule: row, column, diagonal or reading order.
- Work out what the missing piece must be for each rule.
- Rule out every option that breaks any rule. You should be left with one.
If two options seem to fit, you have missed a rule: look again at the property where they differ.
Practise
Like most puzzles, these get easier with practice, because you start to recognise the rules at a glance. There are three free puzzles every day on our free puzzle page, one easy, one medium and one hard, and after each answer you are shown the rule, so you can learn as you go. If you enjoy them, Birthday Patterns in the app has a new set every day with Lucky Coins to win.